Original Article

Incidence of Postdural Puncture Headache and Backache, and Success Rate of Dural Puncture: Comparison of Two Spinal Needle Designs

Authors: Peter H. Pan, MD, MSEE, Regina Fragneto, MD, Charles Moore, PHD, Vernon Ross, MD

Abstract

Objectives: The goal of this randomized study was to compare the incidence of postdural puncture headache (PDPH) and postdural puncture backache (PDPB), and the success rate between two small-gauge spinal needle designs used in women undergoing subarachnoid block anesthesia.


Methods: After Institutional Review Board approval, 215 patients presenting for tubal ligation were randomly assigned to have 26-gauge Atraucan (AT group) or 25-gauge Whitacre (WH group) spinal needles used in their spinal anesthesia. The number of attempts to successful cerebrospinal fluid return and the success rate of the spinal blockade were documented. Postoperatively, an investigator blinded to the study interviewed patients daily.


Results: The incidence of PDPH was similar between the AT group (3.9%) and the WH group (4.0%). The total duration of all PDPHs was 5 days for the AT group and 15 days for the WH group. Both groups had a similar one-attempt success rate of 61% (AT group) and 62% (WH group). Failure to obtain cerebrospinal fluid occurred in only one in the AT group and two in the WH group. The incidence of PDPB was similar and the severity was mild in both groups.


Conclusions: The low complication and failure rates make these two types of smaller size spinal needle design good candidates for dural puncture procedures, such as spinal anesthesia, diagnostic lumbar punctures, and myelograms.

This content is limited to qualifying members.

Existing members, please login first

If you have an existing account please login now to access this article or view purchase options.

Purchase only this article ($25)

Create a free account, then purchase this article to download or access it online for 24 hours.

Purchase an SMJ online subscription ($75)

Create a free account, then purchase a subscription to get complete access to all articles for a full year.

Purchase a membership plan (fees vary)

Premium members can access all articles plus recieve many more benefits. View all membership plans and benefit packages.

References

1. Ross BK, Chadwick HS, Mancuso JJ, et al. Sprotte needle for obstetric anesthesia: Decreased incidence of postdural puncture headache. Reg Anesth 1992; 17: 29–33.
 
2. Cesarini M, Torriellli R, Lahaye F, et al. Sprotte needle for intrathecal anaesthesia for caesarean section: Incidence of postdural puncture headache. Anaesthesia 1990; 45: 656–658.
 
3. Carbaat PA, van Crevel H. Lumbar punctures headache: Controlled study on the preventive effect of 24 hours’ bed rest. Lancet 1981; 2: 1133–1135.
 
4. Holst D, Mollmann M, Ebel C, et al. In vitro investigation of cerebrospinal fluid leakage after dural puncture with various spinal needles. Anesth Analg 1998; 87: 1331–1335.
 
5. Scott DB, Dittmann M, Clough DG, et al. A new needle for spinal anesthesia. Reg Anesth 1993; 18: 213–217.
 
6. Morrison LM, McCrae AF, Foo I, et al. An in vitro comparison of fluid leakage after dural puncture with Atraucan, Sprotte, Whitacre, and Quincke needles. Reg Anesth 1996; 21: 139–143.
 
7. Campbell DC, Douglas MJ, Pavy TJ, et al. Comparison of the 25-gauge Whitacre with the 24-gauge Sprotte spinal needle for elective caesarian section: Cost implications. Can J Anaesth 1993; 40: 1131–1135.
 
8. Shutt LE, Valentine SJ, Wee MY, et al. Spinal anaesthesia for caesarian section: Comparison of 22-gauge and 25-gauge Whitacre needles with 26-gauge Quincke needles. Br J Anaesth 1992; 69: 589–594.
 
9. Lynch J, Kasper SM, Strick K, et al. The use of Quincke and Whitacre 27-gauge needles in orthopedic patients: Incidence of failed spinal anesthesia and postdural puncture headache. Anesth Analg 1994; 79: 124–128.
 
10. Krommendijk EJ, Verheijen R, Dijk B, et al. The Pencan 25-gauge needle: A new pencil-point needle for spinal anesthesia tested in 1193 patients. Reg Anesth Pain Med 1999; 24: 43–50.
 
11. Tarkkila PJ, Heine H, Tervo RR. Comparison of Sprotte and Quincke needles with respect to post dural puncture headache and backache. Reg Anesth 1992; 17: 283–287.
 
12. Mayer DC, Quance D, Weeks SK. Headache after spinal anesthesia for cesarean section: A comparison of the 27-gauge Quincke and 24-gauge Sprotte needles. Anesth Analg 1992; 75: 377–380.
 
13. Sharma SK, Gambling DR, Joshi GP, et al. Comparison of 26-gauge Atraucan and 25-gauge Whitacre needles: Insertion characteristics and complications. Can J Anaesth 1995; 42: 706–710.
 
14. Andres JD, Valia JC, Errando C, et al. Subarachnoid anesthesia in young patients: A comparative analysis of two needle bevels. Reg Anesth Pain Med 1999; 24: 547–552.
 
15. Vallejo MC, Mandell GL, Sabo DP, et al. Postdural puncture headache: A randomized comparison of five spinal needles in obstetric patients. Anesth Analg 2000; 91: 916–920.
 
16. Schultz AM, Ulbing S, Kaider A, et al. Postdural puncture headache and back pain after spinal anesthesia with 27-gauge Quincke and 26-gauge Atraucan needles. Reg Anesth 1996; 21: 461–464.
 
17. Norris MC, Leighton BL, DeSimone CA. Needle bevel direction and headache after inadvertent dural puncture. Anesthesiology 1989; 70: 729–731.
 
18. Mihic DN. Postspinal headache and relationship of needle bevel to longitudinal dural fibers. Reg Anesth 1985; 10: 76–81.
 
19. Lybecker H, Moller JT, May O, et al. Incidence and prediction of postdural puncture headache: A prospective study of 1021 spinal anesthesias. Anesth Analg 1990; 70: 389–394.
 
20. Naulty JS, Hertwig L, Hunt CO, et al. Influence of local anesthetic solution on postdural puncture headache. Anesthesiology 1990; 72: 450–454.
 
21. Brattebo G, Wisborg T, Rodt SA, et al. Intrathecal anaesthesia in patients under 45 years: Incidence of postdural puncture symptoms after spinal anaesthesia with 27-G needles. Acta Anaesthesiol Scand 1993; 37: 545–548.