Original Article

"Murder or Mercy?" An Innovative Module Helping UK Medical Students to Articulate Their Own Ethical Viewpoints Regarding End-of-Life Decisions

Authors: David Bell, PhD, FESC FHEA, Vivienne Crawford, PhD

Abstract

This module was designed to equip UK medical students to respond ethically and sensitively to requests encountered as qualified doctors regarding euthanasia and assisted dying. The aim was to expose students to relevant opinions and experiences and provide opportunities to explore and justify their own views and rehearse ethical decision making in a safe learning environment.


The module is delivered by a multidisciplinary team, providing students with the working knowledge to actively discuss cases, articulate their own views and practice ethical reasoning. Visits to intensive care units, palliative care wards and hospices are integrated with theory. Student assessment comprises a dissertation, debate and reflection. Module impact was evaluated by analysis of student coursework and a questionnaire.


Students greatly appreciated the clinical context provided by the visits and opportunities to apply ethical reasoning to cases and debate issues with peers. They reported increased discernment of the ethical and legal position and practical considerations and greater awareness of the range of professional and lay viewpoints held. Many participants were less strongly in favor of euthanasia and assisted dying on module completion than at the outset, but all of them believed they were better equipped to justify their own viewpoint and respond to patient requests. The multi-disciplinary nature of this course helps to prepare students to deal effectively and sensitively with ethical dilemmas they will encounter in their medical career. Use of an integrated, learner-centred approach equips students to actively engage with their peers in discussion of such issues and to formulate and defend their own position.

This content is limited to qualifying members.

Existing members, please login first

If you have an existing account please login now to access this article or view purchase options.

Purchase only this article ($25)

Create a free account, then purchase this article to download or access it online for 24 hours.

Purchase an SMJ online subscription ($75)

Create a free account, then purchase a subscription to get complete access to all articles for a full year.

Purchase a membership plan (fees vary)

Premium members can access all articles plus recieve many more benefits. View all membership plans and benefit packages.

References

1. Stirrat GM, Johnston C, Gillon R, et al. Medical ethics and law for doctors of tomorrow: the 1998 Consensus Statement updated. J Med Ethics 2010;36:55-60.
 
2. Fox E, Arnold RM, Brody B. Medical education: past, present and future. Acad Med 1995;70:761-769.
 
3. Kenny N, Sargeant J, Allen M. Lifelong learning in ethical practice: a challenge for continuing medical education. J Contin Educ Health Prof 2001;21:24-32.
 
4. Lewin LO, Olson CA, Goodman KW, et al. UME-21 and teaching ethics: a step in the right direction. Fam Med 2004;36(1 suppl):S36-S42.
 
5. Goldie J. Review of ethics curricula in undergraduate medical education. Med Educ 2000;34:108-119.
 
6. General Medical Council. Tomorrow's Doctors. London: GMC; 2003.
 
7. Gurnham D. Losing the wood for the trees: Burke and the Court of Appeal. Med Law Rev 2006;14:253-263.
 
8. The Diane Pretty Case. Available at: http://www.publications.parliament.uk/pa/ld200102/ldjudgmt/jd011129/pretty-1.htm. Accessed August 18, 2011.
 
9. Foggo D. Why Daniel James chose to die. Sunday Times 2008.
 
10. General Medical Council. End of Life Treatment and Care: Good Practice in Decision-Making. London: GMC; 2010.
 
11. Stuart J. A doctor who answered the prayer of a patient desperate to die. Independent 2005.
 
12. The Tony Bland Case. Available at: http://www.bailii.org/uk/cases/UKHL/1992/5.html. Accessed August 18, 2011.
 
13. Stauch M. Comment on Re B (Adult: Refusal of Medical Treatment) [2002] 2 All England Reports 449. J Med Ethics 2002;28:232-233.
 
14. Cavalier R, Covey P, Anderson D. A Right to Die-The Dax Cowart Case: An Ethical Case Study on CD-ROM. London: Routledge; 1996.
 
15. Singer PA, Robb AK. The Ethics OSCE: standardised patient scenarios for teaching and evaluating bioethics. Available at: http://wings.buffalo.edu/bioethics/osce.html. Accessed August 18, 2011.
 
16. Sokol D. Virtual patient. Available at: http://www.elu.sgul.ac.uk/iethics/. Accessed August 18, 2011.
 
17. Steinaker NW, Bell MR. The experiential taxonomy: a new approach to teaching and learning. New York: Academic Press; 1979.
 
18. Lovett LM, Seedhouse D. An innovation in teaching ethics to medical students. Med Educ 1990;24:37-41.
 
19. Caralis PV, Hammond JS. Attitudes of medical students, housestaff and faculty physicians toward euthanasia and termination of life-sustaining treatment. Crit Care Med 1992;20:683-690.
 
20. Roff S, Preece P. Helping medical students to find their moral compasses: ethics teaching for second and third year undergraduates. J Med Ethics 2004;30:487-489.
 
21. Smith S, Fryer-Edwards K, Diekema DS, et al. Finding effective strategies for teaching ethics: a comparison trial of two interventions. Acad Med 2004;79:265-271.
 
22. Sidorov JJ. Education in medical ethics. Gastroenterol Japan 1993;28(6 suppl):3-7.
 
23. Goldie J, Schwartz L, McConnachie A, et al. The impact of a modern medical curriculum on students' proposed behaviour on meeting ethical dilemmas. Med Educ 2004;38:942-949.
 
24. Griffiths S, Partington S. Enabling active learning in small groups. In: Cryer P, ed. Effective Teaching and Learning in Higher Education. Sheffield, UK: CVCP Universities Staff Development Unit; 1993.
 
25. Self DJ, Baldwin DC, Wolinsky FD. Evaluation of teaching medical ethics by an assessment of moral reasoning. Med Educ 1992;26:178-184.
 
26. Myser C, Kerridge IH, Mitchell KR. Teaching clinical ethics as a professional skill: bridging the gap between knowledge about ethics and its use in clinical practice. J Med Ethics 1995;21:97-103.
 
27. Hayward RS, Honer WG. Student-directed teaching of medical ethics in a Canadian medical school.J Med Educ 1985;60:384-389.