Review Article

Relative Merits of Low-Carbohydrate Versus Low-Fat Diet in Managing Obesity

Authors: Irene Alexandraki, MD, MPH, Carlos Palacio, MD, MPH, Arshag D. Mooradian, MD

Abstract

Objectives: Although low-fat diets (LFD) have been the cornerstone of dietary guidelines for weight reduction, low-carbohydrate diets (LCD) continue to gain attention and popularity. Which diet can achieve significant and sustainable weight loss in unclear, however. Our objective in this study was to compare LCDs with LFDs and their impact on weight loss.

Methods: We performed a MEDLINE/PubMed search for English-language articles of randomized controlled studies conducted with adults who were overweight or obese for at least 6 months for the time period of January 2001–October 2014. Two reviewers independently abstracted data, including participants’ characteristics, diet composition and duration, and change in weight from baseline at 6 and 12 months.

Results: A total of 17 studies were analyzed. At 6 months, the mean weight loss for participants on an LCD was −1.439 kg (95% confidence interval −2.319 to −0.558) compared with participants on an LFD ( P < 0.001). At 12 months, the difference was smaller, −0.769 kg (95% confidence interval −1.361 to −0.178) but remained statistically significant ( P < 0.010). The mean difference in the weight loss between the two diets was attenuated over time.

Conclusions: Reducing carbohydrate intake may help patients achieve weight loss. The mean difference in weight change between an LCD and an LFD was too small to have a meaningful impact on weight loss. More studies are needed to better elucidate the role of LCDs in weight loss efforts.

This content is limited to qualifying members.

Existing members, please login first

If you have an existing account please login now to access this article or view purchase options.

Purchase only this article ($25)

Create a free account, then purchase this article to download or access it online for 24 hours.

Purchase an SMJ online subscription ($75)

Create a free account, then purchase a subscription to get complete access to all articles for a full year.

Purchase a membership plan (fees vary)

Premium members can access all articles plus recieve many more benefits. View all membership plans and benefit packages.

References

1. Bessesen DH. Update on obesity. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2008;93:2027-2034.
 
2. Ogden CL, Carroll MD, Kit BK, et al. Prevalence of childhood and adult obesity in the United States, 2011Y2012. JAMA 2014;311:806-814.
 
3. American Diabetes Association, Bantle JP, Wylie-Rosett J, et al. Nutrition recommendations and interventions for diabetes: a position statement of the American Diabetes Association. Diabetes Care 2008;31(1 suppl):S61-S78.
 
4. Wylie-Rosett J, Albright AA, Apovian C, et al. 2006Y2007 American Diabetes Association Nutrition Recommendations: issues for practice translation. J Am Diet Assoc 2007;107:1296-1304.
 
5. Mead A, Atkinson G, Albin D, et al. Dietetic guidelines on food and nutrition in the secondary prevention of cardiovascular disease—evidence from systematic reviews of randomized controlled trials (second update, January 2006). J Hum Nutr Diet 2006;19:401-419.
 
6. American Heart Association Nutrition Committee, Lichtenstein AH, Appel LJ, et al. Diet and lifestyle recommendations revision 2006: a scientific statement from the American Heart Association Nutrition Committee. Circulation 2006;114:82-96.
 
7. US Department of Agriculture and US Department of Health and Human Services. Dietary guidelines for Americans, 2010. 7th ed. http://www.cnpp.usda.gov/sites/default/files/dietary_guidelines_for_americans/PolicyDoc.pdf. Published December 2010. Accessed March 18, 2015.
 
8. Atkins R. Dr. Atkins’ New Diet Revolution. New York: Avon Books; 1998.
 
9. Heller RF. The Carbohydrate Addict’s Diet: The Lifelong Solution to Yo-Yo Dieting. New York: New American Library; 1993.
 
10. Sears B, Lawren B. The Zone: A Dietary Road Map to Lose Weight Permanently, Reset Your Genetic Code, Prevent Disease, Achieve Maximum Physical Performance. New York: Harper Collins; 2005.
 
11. Westman EC, Yancy WS Jr, Mavropoulos JC, et al. The effect of a low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-glycemic index diet on glycemic control in type 2 diabetes mellitus. Nutr Metab (Lond) 2008;5:36.
 
12. Bravata DM, Sanders L, Huang J, et al. Efficacy and safety of low-carbohydrate diets: a systematic review. JAMA 2003;289:1837-1850.
 
13. Westman EC, Feinman RD, Mavropoulos JC, et al. Low-carbohydrate nutrition and metabolism. Am J Clin Nutr 2007;86:276-284.
 
14. Agatston A. South Beach Diet: The Delicious, Doctor-Designed, Foolproff Plan for Fast and Healthy Weight Loss. New York: Random House; 2003.
 
15. Centers for Disease Control and Prevention. Dietary fat. http://www.cdc.gov/nutrition/everyone/basics/fat/index.html?s_cid=tw_ob294. Published 2012. Accessed October 28, 2014.
 
16. Lichtenstein AH, Van Horn L. Very low fat diets. Circulation 1998;98:935-939.
 
17. Watchers Weight. http://www.weightwatchers.com. Accessed October 28, 2014.
 
18. Foster GD, Wyatt HR, Hill JO, et al. Weight and metabolic outcomes after 2 years on a low-carbohydrate versus low-fat diet: a randomized trial. Ann Intern Med 2010;153:147-157.
 
19. Brownell K. The LEARN Manual for Weight Management. Dallas, TX: American Health Publishing; 2000.
 
20. Conley R. www.rosemaryconley.com. Accessed October 28, 2014.
 
21. Ornish D. Eat More, Weigh Less. New York: Harper Collins; 2001.
 
22. Higgins JP, Altman DG, Gøtzsche PC, et al. The Cochrane Collaboration’s tool for assessing risk of bias in randomised trials. BMJ 2011;343:d5928.
 
23. Cochrane Collaboration tool for assessing risk of bias in randomized trials. http://handbook.cochrane.org/index.htm#chapter_8/table_8_4_a_a_common_classification_scheme_for_bias.htm. Accessed February 14, 2015.
 
24. Wallace BC DI, Trikalinos TA, Lau J, et al. Closing the gap between methodologists and end-users: R as a computational back-end. J Stat Softw 2012;49:1-15.
 
25. Gardner CD, Kiazand A, Alhassan S, et al. Comparison of the Atkins, Zone, Ornish, and LEARN diets for change in weight and related risk factors among overweight premenopausal women: the A TO Z Weight Loss Study: a randomized trial. JAMA 2007;297:969-977.
 
26. Truby H, Baic S, deLooy A, et al. Randomised controlled trial of four commercial weight loss programmes in the UK: initial findings from the BBC ‘‘diet trials.’’ BMJ 2006;332:1309-1314.
 
27. Dansinger ML, Gleason JA, Griffith JL, et al. Comparison of the Atkins, Ornish, Weight Watchers, and Zone diets for weight loss and heart disease risk reduction: a randomized trial. JAMA 2005;293:43-53.
 
28. Foster GD, Wyatt HR, Hill JO, et al. A randomized trial of a low-carbohydrate diet for obesity. N Engl J Med 2003;348:2082-2090.
 
29. Bazzano LA, Hu T, Reynolds K, et al. Effects of low-carbohydrate and low-fat diets: a randomized trial. Ann Intern Med 2014;161:309-318.
 
30. Haufe S, Engeli S, Kast P, et al. Randomized comparison of reduced fat and reduced carbohydrate hypocaloric diets on intrahepatic fat in overweight and obese human subjects. Hepatology 2011;53:1504-1514.
 
31. Iqbal N, Vetter ML, Moore RH, et al. Effects of a low-intensity intervention that prescribed a low-carbohydrate vs. a low-fat diet in obese, diabetic participants. Obesity (Silver Spring) 2010;18:1733-1738.
 
32. Davis NJ, Tomuta N, Schechter C, et al. Comparative study of the effects of a 1-year dietary intervention of a low-carbohydrate diet versus a low-fat diet on weight and glycemic control in type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care 2009;32:1147-1152.
 
33. Frisch S, Zittermann A, Berthold HK, et al. A randomized controlled trial on the efficacy of carbohydrate-reduced or fat-reduced diets in patients attending a telemedically guided weight loss program. Cardiovasc Diabetol 2009;8:36.
 
34. Shai I, Schwarzfuchs D, Henkin Y, et al. Weight loss with a lowcarbohydrate, Mediterranean, or low-fat diet. N Engl J Med 2008;359: 229-241.
 
35. Tay J, Brinkworth GD, Noakes M, et al. Metabolic effects of weight loss on a very-low-carbohydrate diet compared with an isocaloric high-carbohydrate diet in abdominally obese subjects. J Am Coll Cardiol 2008;51:59Y-67.
 
36. Swenson BR, Saalwachter Schulman A, Edwards MJ, et al. The effect of a low-carbohydrate, high-protein diet on post laparoscopic gastric bypass weight loss: a prospective randomized trial. J Surg Res 2007;142:308-313.
 
37. Ebbeling CB, Leidig MM, Feldman HA, et al. Effects of a low-glycemic load vs low-fat diet in obese young adults: a randomized trial. JAMA 2007;297:2092-2102.
 
38. Yancy WS Jr, Olsen MK, Guyton JR, et al. A low-carbohydrate, ketogenic diet versus a low-fat diet to treat obesity and hyperlipidemia: a randomized, controlled trial. Ann Intern Med 2004;140:769-777.
 
39. Samaha FF, Iqbal N, Seshadri P, et al. A low-carbohydrate as compared with a low-fat diet in severe obesity. N Engl J Med 2003;348:2074-2081.
 
40. Brehm BJ, Seeley RJ, Daniels SR, et al. A randomized trial comparing a very low carbohydrate diet and a calorie-restricted low fat diet on body weight and cardiovascular risk factors in healthy women. J Clin Endocrinol Metab 2003;88:1617-1623.
 
41. Nordmann AJ, Nordmann A, Briel M, et al. Effects of low-carbohydrate vs low-fat diets on weight loss and cardiovascular risk factors: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled trials. Arch Intern Med 2006;166:285-293.
 
42. Hu T, Mills KT, Yao L, et al. Effects of low-carbohydrate diets versus low-fat diets on metabolic risk factors: a meta-analysis of randomized controlled clinical trials. Am J Epidemiol 2012;176(7 suppl):S44-S54.
 
43. Freedman MR, King J, Kennedy E. Popular diets: a scientific review. Obes Res 2001;9(1 suppl):1S-40.
 
44. Bray GA. Low-carbohydrate diets and realities of weight loss. JAMA 2003;289:1853-1855.
 
45. Ebbeling CB, Swain JF, Feldman HA, et al. Effects of dietary composition on energy expenditure during weight-loss maintenance. JAMA 2012;307:2627-2634.
 
46. Miller CK, Jensen GL, Achterberg CL. Evaluation of a food label nutrition intervention for women with type 2 diabetes mellitus. J Am Diet Assoc 1999;99:323-328.
 
47. Franz MJ, Powers MA, Leontos C, et al. The evidence for medical nutrition therapy for type 1 and type 2 diabetes in adults. J Am Diet Assoc 2010;110:1852-1889.
 
48. Wadden TA, Butryn ML, Hong PS, et al. Behavioral treatment of obesity in patients encountered in primary care settings: a systematic review. JAMA 2014;312:1779-1791.
 
49. Johnston BC, Kanters S, Bandayrel K, et al. Comparison of weight loss among named diet programs in overweight and obese adults: a metaanalysis. JAMA 2014;312:923-933.
 
50. Valsamakis G, McTernan PG, Chetty R, et al. Modest weight loss and reduction in waist circumference after medical treatment are associated with favorable changes in serum adipocytokines. Metabolism 2004;53:430-43.
 
51. Goldstein DJ. Beneficial health effects of modest weight loss. Int J Obes Relat Metab Disord 1992;16:397-415.
 
52. Wing RR, Lang W, Wadden TA, et al. Benefits of modest weight loss in improving cardiovascular risk factors in overweight and obese individuals with type 2 diabetes. Diabetes Care 2011;34:1481-1486.