The Southern Medical Journal (SMJ) is the official, peer-reviewed journal of the Southern Medical Association. It has a multidisciplinary and inter-professional focus that covers a broad range of topics relevant to physicians and other healthcare specialists.

SMJ // Article

Original Article

Practical Wisdom Through Narratives as Told by Medical Students and Physicians

Authors: Jordan D. Millhollin, MD, Elaine Liang, BA, Zachary Loveless, PhD, Sarah Kim, BA, Laura Shinkunas, MS, Tavinder K. Ark, PhD, Lauris C. Kaldjian, MD, PhD, Fabrice Jotterand, PhD, MA, John D. Yoon, MD

Abstract

Objective: Medicine, as both clinical and moral practice, is increasingly complex. As such, there is growing appreciation for the importance of practical wisdom (phronesis), a multidimensional capacity that clinicians develop as they navigate practice. Narrative serves as a mode by which clinical exemplars communicate wisdom and therefore provides a rich structure through which practical wisdom can be observed as manifest in lived experience. The purpose of this study was to analyze clinical phronesis narratives to uncover how participants understand practical wisdom through the real-life challenges of clinical encounters.

Methods: This article describes a qualitative study using structured interviews of 62 participants (40 medical students and 22 physicians). Phronesis narratives describe a particular clinical situation involving an ethically or professionally challenging patient case in which respondents thought practical wisdom was demonstrated.

Results: Narratives frequently identified practical wisdom as being needed in encounters involving patient advocacy, individualized patient care, and communication skills. Character traits associated with practical wisdom included empathy, patience, and emotional intelligence. Narratives most often revealed dimensions of practical wisdom such as person centeredness, poise, or goal-directed decision making. Findings confirm the clinical relevance and multiple dimensions of practical wisdom in medicine "in vivo" that had previously been described theoretically "in vitro." Analysis also revealed that clinical medical students appear able to observe practical wisdom in their supervising physicians, highlighting the need for role-modeling by wise exemplars.

Conclusions: The moral content of clinical medicine can be illuminated by rich narratives that can assist in the formation of wise clinicians. Based on the richness of moral content found in these phronesis narratives, the inclusion of narrative-based practices in medical education may help cultivate practical wisdom in medicine.

This content is limited to qualifying members.

Existing members, please login first

If you have an existing account please login now to access this article or view purchase options.

Purchase only this article ($25)

Create a free account, then purchase this article to download or access it online for 24 hours.

Purchase an SMJ online subscription ($75)

Create a free account, then purchase a subscription to get complete access to all articles for a full year.

Purchase a membership plan (fees vary)

Premium members can access all articles plus recieve many more benefits. View all membership plans and benefit packages.

References

1. Aristotle. Nicomachean Ethics. Indianapolis, IN:Hackett Publishing; 2014.
2. Kristjá K. Phronesis as an ideal in professional medical ethics: some preliminary positionings and problematics. Theor Med Bioeth 2015;36:299-320.
3. Pellegrino ED, Thomasma DC. The Virtues in Medical Practice. New York:Oxford University Press; 1993.
4. Kaldjian LC. Teaching practical wisdom in medicine through clinical judgement, goals of care, and ethical reasoning. J Med Ethics 2010;36:558-562.
5. Marcum JA. The Virtuous Physician: The Role of Virtue in Medicine. New York:Springer; 2012.
6. Plews-Ogan M, Sharpe KE. Phronesis in Medical Practice: The Will and the Skill Needed to Do the Right Thing Brown MEL, Veen M, Finn GM. Applied Philosophy for Health Professions Education: A Journey Towards Mutual Understanding. New York:Springer Nature;2022:293-309.
7. Jotterand F, Amodio A, Elger BS. Patient education as empowerment and self-rebiasing. Med Health Care Philos 2016;19:553-561.
8. Jameel S, Peterson A, Arthur J. Ethics and the Good Doctor : Character in the Professional Domain. London:Routledge; 2022.
9. Edmondson R, Pearce J, Woerner MH. Wisdom in clinical reasoning and medical practice. Theor Med Bioeth 2009;30:231-247.
10. Chiavaroli N, Trumble S. When I say … phronesis. Med Educ 2018;52:1005-1007.
11. Conroy M, Malik AY, Hale C, et al. Using practical wisdom to facilitate ethical decision-making: a major empirical study of phronesis in the decision narratives of doctors. BMC Med Ethics 2021;22:16.
12. Kotzee B, Paton A, Conroy M. Towards an Empirically Informed Account of Phronesis in Medicine. Perspect Biol Med 2016;59:337-350.
13. Paton A, Kotzee B. The fundamental role of storytelling and practical wisdom in facilitating the ethics education of junior doctors. Health (London) 2021;25:417-433.
14. Epstein RM. Reflection, perception and the acquisition of wisdom. Med Educ 2008;42:1048-1050.
15. Tyreman S. Promoting critical thinking in health care: phronesis and criticality. Med Health Care Philos 2000;3:117-124.
16. Davis FD. Phronesis, clinical reasoning, and Pellegrino’ philosophy of medicine. Theor Med 1997;18:173-195.
17. Malik A, Conroy M, Turner C. Phronesis in Medical Ethics: Courage and Motivation to Keep on the Track of Rightness in Decision-Making. Health Care Anal 2020;28:158-175.
18. Kok N, Zegers M, van der Hoeven H, et al. Morisprudence: a theoretical framework for studying the relationship linking moral case deliberation, organisational learning and quality improvement. J Med Ethics 2022;48:868-876.
19. Kinghorn WA. Medical education as moral formation: an Aristotelian account of medical professionalism. Perspect Biol Med 2010;53:87-105.
20. Kotzee B, Ignatowicz A. Measuring “” in medicine. Med Health Care Philos 2016;19:149-161.
21. Svenaeus F. Hermeneutics of medicine in the wake of Gadamer: the issue of phronesis. Theor Med Bioeth 2003;24:407-431.
22. Svenaeus F. Empathy as a necessary condition of phronesis: a line of thought for medical ethics. Med Health Care Philos 2014;17:293-299.
23. Beresford EB. Can phronesis save the life of medical ethics? Theor Med 1996;17:209-224.
24. D’Angelo JD, Cook DA, D’Angelo ALD. Scrubbing With Aristotle: Cultivating Surgical Wisdom through Inflection Points. J Surg Educ 2023;80:1751-1754.
25. George AJ, Urch CE, Cribb A. A virtuous framework for professional reflection. Future Healthc J 2023;10:78-81.
26. Cosgrove L, Shaughnessy AF. Becoming a Phronimos: Evidence-Based Medicine, Clinical Decision Making, and the Role of Practical Wisdom in Primary Care. J Am Board Fam Med 2023;36:531-536.
27. Elledge R, Brennan PA, Mohamud A, et al. Phronesis and virtue ethics: the future of surgical training? Br J Oral Maxillofac Surg 2020;58:125-128.
28. Paes P. Practical wisdom, a dormant character in medical education? Med Educ 2019;53:428-429.
29. Paes P, Leat D, Stewart J. Complex decision making in medical training: key internal and external influences in developing practical wisdom. Med Educ 2019;53:165-174.
30. Bontemps-Hommen MCML, Vosman FJH, Baart AJ. The multiple faces of practical wisdom in complex clinical practices: An empirical exploration. J Eval Clin Pract 2020;26:1034-1041.
31. Collier KM. What is medicine for? BMJ Leader 2024;8:55-58.
32. Jameel SY. Enacted Phronesis in General Practitioners. 2022. Accessed December 21, 2023. https://etheses.bham.ac.uk/id/eprint/12197.
33. Kaldjian LC. Practicing Medicine and Ethics: Integrating Wisdom, Conscience, and Goals of Care. Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press; 2014.
34. Jotterand F, Derse A, Spellecy R, et al. Practical wisdom, clinical judgments and the agential view. J Med Philos 2025;50:147-158.
35. Kaldjian LC, Yoon J, Ark TK, et al. Practical wisdom in medicine through the eyes of medical students and physicians. Med Educ 2023;57:1219-1229.
36. Bontemps-Hommen CMML, Baart A, Vosman FTH. Practical wisdom in complex medical practices: a critical proposal. Med Health Care Philos 2019;22:95-105.
37. Nortvedt P, Vosman F. An ethics of care: new perspectives, both theoretically and empirically? Nurs Ethics 2014;21:753-754.
38. Swartz AL, , Tisdell EJ. Wisdom, Complexity, and Adult Education: Emerging Theory and Meanings for Practice. Accessed February 28, 2026. https://newprairiepress.org/cgi/viewcontent.cgi?referer=&httpsredir=1&article=3093&context=aerc. Accessed February 28, 2026.
39. Klaver K, van Elst E, Baart AJ. Demarcation of the ethics of care as a discipline: discussion article. Nurs Ethics 2014;21:755-765.
40. Woodruff JN. Accounting for complexity in medical education: a model of adaptive behaviour in medicine. Med Educ 2019;53:861-873.
41. Boudreau D, Wykretowicz H, Kinsella EA, et al. Discovering clinical phronesis. Med Health Care Philos 2024;27:165-179.
42. Nelson HL, Brody H. Who gets to tell the story: narrative in postmodern bioethics Lindemann Nelson H. Stories and Their Limits: Narrative Approaches to Bioethics. London:Routledge;1997;:18-30.
43. Murray TH. What do we mean by “ ethics. Med Humanit Rev 1997;11:44-57.
44. Nussbaum MC. Love’ Knowledge: Essays on Philosophy and Literature. New York:Oxford University Press; 1992.
45. Charon R. At the membranes of care: stories in narrative medicine. Acad Med 2012;87:342-347.
46. Loveless Z. Phronesis, Experience, and Self-Cultivation. Birmingham, UK:MA dissertation, University of Birmingham; 2023.
47. Wald HS, Reis SP. Beyond the margins: reflective writing and development of reflective capacity in medical education. J Gen Intern Med 2010;25:746-749.
48. Bryan CS, Babelay AM. Building character: a model for reflective practice. Acad Med 2009;84:1283-1288.
49. Tong A, Sainsbury P, Craig J. Consolidated criteria for reporting qualitative research (COREQ): a 32-item checklist for interviews and focus groups. Int J Qual Health Care 2007;19:349-357.
50. Brienza JP, Kung FYH, Santos HC, et al. Wisdom, bias, and balance: Toward a process-sensitive measurement of wisdom-related cognition. J Pers Soc Psychol 2018;115:1093-1126.
51. Hsieh HF, Shannon SE. Three approaches to qualitative content analysis. Qual Health Res 2005;15:1277-1288.
52. Annas J. The Morality of Happiness. New York:Oxford University Press; 1995.
53. Leffel GM, Oakes Mueller RA, Curlin FA, et al. Relevance of the rationalist-intuitionist debate for ethics and professionalism in medical education. Adv Health Sci Educ Theory Pract 2015;20:1371-1383.
54. Hawking M, Frush B, Yoon JD. Towards an End: Perseverance in Medical Training and Practice. In: King NL, ed. The Virtue of Endurance. New York:Oxford University Press;2025. chap 10.
55. Dott C, Mamarelis G, Karam E, et al. Emotional Intelligence and Good Medical Practice: Is There a Relationship? Cureus. 202514:e23126.
56. Codier E, Codier D. A model for the role of emotional intelligence in patient safety. Asia Pac J Oncol Nurs 2015;2:112-117.
57. Nightingale S, Spiby H, Sheen K, et al. The impact of emotional intelligence in health care professionals on caring behaviour towards patients in clinical and long-term care settings: Findings from an integrative review. Int J Nurs Stud 2018;80:106-117.
58. Kristjá K, Fowers B, Darnell C, et al. Phronesis (Practical Wisdom) as a Type of Contextual Integrative Thinking. Rev Gen Psychol 2021;25:239-257.
59. Kristjánsson K, Darnell C, Fowers B, et al. Phronesis: Developing a conceptualisation and an instrument. 2020. Accessed February 28, 2026. https://www.jubileecentre.ac.uk/wp-content/uploads/2023/12/Phronesis_DevelopingAndValidatingAShortMeasureOfPracticalWisdom-_Final-1.pdf.
60. De Caro M, Vaccarezza MS. Practical Wisdom: Philosophical and Psychological Perspectives. London:Routledge; 2021.
62. Jotterand F, Kim DT. The New Science of Practical Wisdom: A Critical Appraisal. J Med Philos 2025;50:75-79.
63. Epstein RM, Siegel DJ, Silberman J. Self-monitoring in clinical practice: a challenge for medical educators. J Contin Educ Health Prof 2008;28:5-13.
64. Schon DA. The Reflective Practitioner: How Professionals Think in Action, 1st ed. New York:Basic Books; 1984.
65. Eve P, Kangas M. Posttraumatic growth following trauma: Is growth accelerated or a reflection of cognitive maturation? Hum Psychol 2015;43:354-370.
66. Mezirow J. On Critical Reflection. Adult Educ Q 1998;48:185-198.
67. Montgomery A, Doulougeri K, Panagopoulou E. Do critical incidents lead to critical reflection among medical students? Health Psychol Behav Med 2021;9:206-219.
68. Zelazo PD. Executive function: Reflection, iterative reprocessing, complexity, and the developing brain. Dev Rev 2015;38:55-68.
69. Abdulnour REE, Parsons AS, Muller D, et al. Deliberate Practice at the Virtual Bedside to Improve Clinical Reasoning. N Engl J Med 2022;386:1946-1947.
70. Liao HC, Wang YH. Narrative medicine and humanities for health professions education: an experimental study. Med Educ Online 2023;28:2235749.
71. Glück J, Bluck S, Weststrate NM. More on the MORE Life Experience Model: What We Have Learned (So Far). J Value Inq 2019;53:349-370.
72. Weststrate N, Glück J. Hard-Earned Wisdom: Exploratory Processing of Difficult Life Experience is Positively Associated with Wisdom. Dev Psychol 2017;53:800-814.
73. Le TN. Cultural values, life experiences, and wisdom. Int J Aging Hum Dev 2008;66:259-281.
74. Bluck S, Glück J. Making things better and learning a lesson: experiencing wisdom across the lifespan. J Pers 2004;72:543-572.
75. Aristotle. Poetics. Indianapolis, IN:Hackett Publishing; 1987.
76. Zagzebski L. Moral exemplars in theory and practice. Theory Res Educ 2013;11:193-206.
77. Mischinski M, Jayawickreme E. Can Moral Exemplars Promote Wisdom? Sternberg RJ, Nusbaum HC, Gl࿌ J. Applying Wisdom to Contemporary World Problems. New York:Springer; 2019:173-200.
78. Sternberg RJ, Nusbaum HC, Gl࿌ J. Applying Wisdom to Contemporary World Problems. New York:Springer; 2019.
79. Pellegrino ED. Toward a virtue-based normative ethics for the health professions. Kennedy Inst Ethics J 1995;5:253-277.
80. Hawking M, Kim J, Jih M, et al. Can virtue be taught?”: a content analysis of medical students’ opinions of the professional and ethical challenges to their professional identity formation. BMC Med Educ 2020;20:380.
81. Larkin GL, Iserson K, Kassutto Z, et al. Virtue in emergency medicine. Acad Emerg Med 2009;16:51-55.
82. Beauchamp TL, Childress JF. Principles of Biomedical Ethics, 8th ed. New York:Oxford University Press; 2019.
83. Kotzee B, Ignatowicz A, Thomas H. Virtue in Medical Practice: An Exploratory Study. HEC Forum 2017;29:1-19.
84. Gauthier CC. Teaching the virtues: justifications and recommendations. Camb Q Healthc Ethics 1997;6:339-346.
85. Oakley J, Cocking D. Virtue Ethics and Professional Roles. Cambridge, UK:Cambridge University Press; 2001.
86. Drane JF. Becoming a Good Doctor: The Place of Virtue and Character in Medical Ethics. Lanham, MD:Rowman & Littlefield; 1988.
87. Huber A, Strecker C, Kachel T, et al. Character Strengths Profiles in Medical Professionals and Their Impact on Well-Being. Front Psychol 2020;11:566728.
88. Heaton J. Secondary analysis of qualitative data. 1998. Accessed January 13, 2025. https://sru.soc.surrey.ac.uk/SRU22.html.
89. Doukas DJ, Ozar DT, Darragh M, et al. Virtue and care ethics & humanism in medical education: a scoping review. BMC Med Educ 2022;22:131.
90. Kim DT, Applewhite MK, Shelton W. Professional Identity Formation in Medical Education: Some Virtue-Based Insights. Teach Learn Med 2024;36:399-409.
91. Lyon W. Virtue and medical ethics education. Philos Ethics Humanit Med 2021;16:2.
92. Seoane L, Tompkins LM, De Conciliis A, et al. Virtues Education in Medical School: The Foundation for Professional Formation. Ochsner J 2016;16:50-55.
93. Sulmasy DP. Should Medical Schools Be Schools for Virtue? J Gen Intern Med 2000;15:514-516.